Garden Ministry Pumpkin Pies

Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pies

“Gratitude is the memory of the heart.”

Every pie is homemade with love using Long Island cheese pumpkins grown by the Garden Ministry of the Sisters of St. Joseph.
To Order:Call Heather at (631)838-0013 or email

Indicate when you would like to pick up your pie.

Pie Pick-Up Times: Tuesday, November 20 from 11:00AM-1:00PM or 5:00PM – 7:00PM

Limited supply only. First come, first served.
One pie per family. We appreciate your donation.

The Long Island cheese pumpkin is one of the oldest heirloom squash varieties cultivated in America. They were a regional favorite until seed retailers began to replace them with pumpkins of a more uniform size and shape. Thanks to a few heirloom seed savers, we have pies made with these baking beauties to share with you today